Hair loss is a sign, and the same complaint ("my hair is thinning") can come from a dozen conditions with very different treatments. Dermatologists sort them with a fairly consistent sequence: the pattern of loss, how fast it started, what a pull test shows, what the scalp looks like under a dermatoscope (trichoscopy), and a targeted set of blood tests. This guide lays out that sequence and puts the main causes side by side, so you can see why a clinician asks the questions they do.
Step one: two questions that split the field
- Is it diffuse or focal? Diffuse thinning across the top or the whole scalp points toward pattern hair loss or telogen effluvium. Well-defined patches point toward alopecia areata, tinea capitis, traction or hair pulling.
- Are follicular openings still there? In non-scarring hair loss the follicles survive and regrowth is possible. In scarring (cicatricial) alopecia, follicles are destroyed; on trichoscopy, absent follicles suggest scarring alopecia (StatPearls, alopecia areata). Scarring loss is the main reason not to wait and see.
The American Academy of Dermatology notes that more than one cause can be present at once, which is why a dermatologist may need several pieces of information before settling on a diagnosis (AAD).
Differential diagnosis at a glance
| Condition | Typical pattern | Onset | Trichoscopy clues | Usual workup |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Androgenetic alopecia | Temples and crown in men; widening central part in women | Gradual, after puberty | Hair shaft diameter variability, vellus hairs, peripilar sign | Clinical; thyroid, CBC and iron studies to exclude contributors |
| Telogen effluvium | Diffuse shedding, scalp looks healthy | About 2-4 months after a trigger | Non-specific: single-hair follicle units, upright regrowing hairs | CBC, metabolic panel, TSH, ferritin; others by history |
| Alopecia areata | Smooth round patches; may affect beard, brows, lashes | Sudden, over weeks | Yellow dots, black dots, exclamation mark hairs | Clinical; other autoimmune tests only if history suggests |
| Trichotillomania | Patches, typically frontoparietal, with hairs broken at different lengths; may include brows and lashes | Variable | Black dots, flame hairs, V-hairs, split ends, hair powder | Clinical; biopsy if unclear |
| Tinea capitis | Patchy loss with or without scale and broken hairs, mainly in children | Variable | Comma, corkscrew and zigzag hairs | KOH microscopy of plucked hairs and scale; fungal culture when needed |
| Traction alopecia | Hairline and areas under tension from tight styles | Gradual | Pinpoint white dots, reduced follicular openings, peripilar casts | Clinical history of styling |
| Lichen planopilaris / frontal fibrosing alopecia | Patchy (LPP) or receding frontal band, often with brow loss (FFA) | Usually gradual | Perifollicular redness and scale, white fibrotic dots, lost follicular openings, lonely hairs | Scalp biopsy |
| Discoid lupus | Red, scaly, scarring plaques | Usually gradual | Follicular plugs, thick branching vessels, pink-white background | Scalp biopsy |
| Central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia | Starts at the crown and spreads outward | Usually gradual | Grey-white halo around follicles, pinpoint white dots | Scalp biopsy |
Trichoscopy features from a 2026 systematic review (Gowda et al., Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol), whose authors caution that terminology varies and validated diagnostic criteria are lacking. Pattern and workup from Phillips et al., Am Fam Physician 2017, StatPearls, Bergfeld and Mendez, Cleve Clin J Med 2026 and Merck Manual.
How the pull test is actually done
The pull test is simple, but technique changes the result. In the method described by Bergfeld and Mendez, the clinician grasps about 50 to 60 hairs close to the scalp, pulls gently from root to tip, and repeats this in several areas. A positive result is 5 or more telogen hairs in one pull, or more than 15 after three pulls. It should be done 2 to 3 days after shampooing: washing just beforehand can give a false negative, and skipping washing or combing for several days can give a false positive. Pulled hairs are checked under magnification for the small club-shaped bulb of a resting hair.
A positive test says hair is shedding actively; it does not say why. A positive pull test at the edge of a patch suggests active alopecia areata, while a diffusely positive test with a healthy scalp fits telogen effluvium.
Which blood tests, and when
There is no single "hair loss panel." For shedding, Bergfeld and Mendez list screening tests for all patients:
- Complete blood count, for anemia
- Comprehensive metabolic panel, for systemic disease
- TSH, for thyroid disease
- Ferritin, for iron stores
Additional tests are chosen by history: 25-hydroxyvitamin D when nutritional deficiency is suspected, a hormonal evaluation in women with signs of androgen excess such as acne or virilization, and antinuclear antibodies when features suggest an immune-mediated disorder. StatPearls adds syphilis testing when it is clinically suspected. Tests beyond these are guided by the history; how specific deficiencies relate to shedding is covered in our vitamins and hair loss review.
Clues hiding in the history and nails
- Timing back from the shed. Telogen effluvium typically starts about 2 to 4 months after the trigger: childbirth, a febrile illness, surgery, psychological stress, rapid weight loss or a crash diet (DermNet). Rapid weight loss on GLP-1 drugs is a current example (GLP-1 drugs and shedding).
- Beau lines. A horizontal groove across the nails marks a past systemic shock. A fingernail takes about 5 months to grow out, so a groove halfway down suggests the event was roughly 2.5 months ago (DermNet).
- Spoon-shaped nails (koilonychia) suggest iron deficiency (Bergfeld and Mendez).
- Nail pitting occurs in about 10% to 15% of people with alopecia areata (StatPearls).
- Broken rather than shed hairs suggest heat or chemical damage, pulling, or a hair shaft disorder.
- Scale and itch. Thick scale, redness or pustules are not typical of telogen effluvium and point to inflammatory scalp disease such as seborrheic dermatitis or psoriasis (seborrheic dermatitis and hair loss).
Overlaps that cause misdiagnosis
Telogen effluvium and pattern hair loss frequently coexist. A shed can unmask underlying androgenetic alopecia, and on trichoscopy female pattern hair loss shows more variation in shaft diameter than acute telogen effluvium (Bergfeld and Mendez). Acute telogen effluvium usually peaks and then tapers back to normal over about 6 to 9 months once the trigger is removed, though recovery is sometimes incomplete (DermNet). If thinning persists beyond that, the question shifts to whether pattern loss was there all along.
Alopecia areata has its own course to factor in. About half of patients regrow hair within a year without treatment, but most have recurrences and around 10% of patchy cases progress to total scalp or body hair loss (StatPearls).
When a biopsy is the right call
A biopsy is reserved for cases where history, exam and pull test leave the diagnosis uncertain, for suspected chronic telogen effluvium, and for suspected scarring alopecia, which primary care guidance says should be referred to a dermatologist when follicular openings are absent (Phillips et al.). Bergfeld and Mendez describe a 4-mm punch that includes subcutaneous fat, often taken as two samples (one cut vertically, one horizontally), from an area of thinning rather than complete baldness.
Checklist: what to bring to the appointment
- When shedding or thinning started, and anything that happened 2 to 4 months before
- All medicines and supplements, including start dates and recent dose changes
- Recent weight change, diet changes, pregnancy or illness
- Family history of hair loss on both sides
- Your styling routine: tight styles, extensions, relaxers, heat
- Photos of the same scalp areas over time, in the same light
- Recent blood results, if you have them
Don't wait for a routine appointment if you notice
- Burning, pain or itching in an area of hair loss, or redness around the follicles
- Shiny skin where follicle openings seem to have disappeared, or a receding band at the front with eyebrow loss
- A child with scaly patches and broken hairs: tinea capitis needs oral antifungal treatment, as topical products alone are not enough
- Patches that are spreading quickly, or loss of eyebrows, eyelashes or body hair
Scarring hair loss is permanent once follicles are destroyed, so early assessment by a dermatologist matters most in exactly these cases.